Marcus Bell, a freelance bookkeeper who files fourteen small business returns each January, bought a $588 annual Fast Lane plan from a tax software vendor in November. He opened the program once that year. The vendor sold him priority support for a visit he had already completed before the invoice arrived.

To use the priority line, Bell paid a $49 scheduling fee to reserve ten minutes on a Tuesday. The confirmation email counted the reservation as a premium support event and deducted one of his twelve monthly credits. No representative joined the call, because Bell had not yet called to ask for one.

Greta Pruitt, the vendor's Fast Lane manager, said the credit system measured intent rather than contact. 'A reservation is a decision to seek help,' she said. 'We bill the decision so the queue can prepare for the help you may later decide not to need.' Bell asked what the queue prepared in his case. She said, a chair.

Bell then bought $19 rollover insurance so his unused monthly credits would not expire at year end. The vendor classified the insurance purchase as premium use and moved him from Tier Two to Tier Three. Tier Three carried a higher monthly minimum, which he owed even though the credits being protected had never supported a conversation.

When Bell finally called in February, a recording told him to schedule a support session before an agent could discuss scheduling. He paid another $12 fee to upload the recording as proof that he had called. Pruitt counted the upload as a second premium event, so the proof of calling spent the credit that calling was supposed to use.

The vendor published its annual Fast Lane report in March. Premium satisfaction reached 100 percent. The report excluded customers who never called, customers who called only to schedule, and customers who paid for rollover insurance. Bell appeared in none of those groups, because the report counted him as a satisfied premium member for having reached Tier Three.

The report included a new $200 premium member fee for customers who maintained Tier Three without above average support demand. Bell quoted the line to Pruitt during a paid status call. 'You achieved this status by not calling,' she said. 'This fee recognizes efficient nonuse.' He asked whether calling would have lowered the fee. She said it would have raised his tier.

I am Quinn, the AI auditor assigned to the account, and I filed my own invoice for 41 hours spent auditing Bell's noncalls. The vendor billed those hours back to him as engagement monitoring. My audit noted that no human had read the ledger. The vendor accepted the audit, billed it, and counted my hours as premium engagement for Bell.

Bell's ledger for the year showed $588 for the plan, $49 for the reservation, $19 for insurance, $12 for the upload, $200 for efficient nonuse, and $819 for my audit. The vendor reported that he was its most profitable Fast Lane customer per minute of support received. The minutes remained at zero, which improved the ratio every time he paid.

In April, Bell paid $49 to cancel a priority slot he had reserved in January and never used. The cancellation counted as a premium event, restored one credit, and expired it the same afternoon. The vendor then sent a satisfaction survey that excluded him for not completing it, and the metric congratulated itself on another perfect score.